6

When setting up a project, what are the advantages and disadvantages to using Summary Tasks vs Detail tasks as predecessors?

If it matters, I am experimenting with MS Project 2010 as a tool.

6

Personal preference, but for me, I only group them by like kind (summary to summary, detail to detail).

Summary tasks are seen as separate work packages, ie: they summarize all of the tasks necessary to complete that particular part of the project. So if I link a Summary task to anything, it will be to another summary task (work package).

This also helps in the rollup view, as I can see how the various summaries (work packages) link together, with no linkages lost in the view.

5

I second Trevor's answer but would remove 'personal preference.' The schedule logic rests at your leaf level of the decomposition. Everything that matters to you as a PM occurs at this level; at the summary levels, things become hidden and your critical path becomes clugy. If you mix your predecessor-successor logic between levels, you will, not may, lose sight of accrued variances. They will not surface until later and you want to know these things earlier.

  • Thanks David. I added personal pref only because, as you know, when it comes PM's, there are no 'rules'. :) – Trevor K. Nelson May 8 '12 at 3:16
3

I wouldn't recommend linking summary tasks in MS Project for the following reasons:

  • it can make the logic difficult to follow, and make it hard to identify the Critical Path
  • it can cause logic errors which artifically extend the plan
  • it can lead to unnecessary bench time.
  • it can cause circular logic warnings

See http://www.stakeholdermap.com/ms-project/link-summary-tasks-ms-project.html for more information.

  • Welcome to PM:SE. +1 to the answer thank you for being informative, terse and providing a solid useful reference – Mark C. Wallace Nov 9 '12 at 19:58

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.