The following exchange took place in the comments to an answer to another question [https://pm.stackexchange.com/questions/33267/how-do-i-manage-development-with-testing-and-get-proper-reporting-in-jira][1], which seem to highlight a different viewpoint between the principles of Agile, which is all about delivery of value, and the desire of a Resource Manager to keep people working / contributing at all times. I have highlighted the key elements in **Bold**. There is a fundamental difference between these positions, so what is, or what should be, the role of a resource manager in an Agile (Scrum) environment?

Please don't answer this by reference to restructuring into multidisciplined teams - that's not my question. It is purely to do with the organisational roles of resource managers in an Agile environment, and how much they should be involved / interested in what individuals are doing on a daily basis.

Edit: I am neither a resource manager nor an Agile practitioner, so I'm not asking this question with any pre-formed opinions. I just wonder what the community's view is on the subject.

----------

*"For example... why is development wrapping up at 5pm on Friday, instead of at 5pm on Thursday so the work can be tested on Friday?" - let's say they will finish on Thursday, so what will they do on Friday?? –* 
user48230
 yesterday

*@user48230 That's the 100% utilization fallacy. **The goal isn't to keep people busy; the goal is to deliver increments of value on a dependable cadence.** You have implemented the wrong goal.* – 
Todd A. Jacobs
♦
 16 hours ago

*@ToddA.Jacobs - you do have a point, 100%. still, **as a resource manager I also have to ensure that people are delivering value on Friday 9-17** while QA is finishing up the testing. –* 
user48230
 15 hours ago
1

*@user48230 **No. In a Scrum environment, the "value" being delivered on Friday is the demonstration/review with the stakeholders, not "more work."** If no one else takes this into account, I'll write a longer answer when I can. Value in Scrum isn't about busy-ness; it's about consistency, quick feedback, and collaboration. –* 
Todd A. Jacobs
♦
 13 hours ago


  [1]: https://pm.stackexchange.com/questions/33267/how-do-i-manage-development-with-testing-and-get-proper-reporting-in-jira