Skip to main content
Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackProjects/status/500048285475020802
Clarify question and retrofit for the Q&A format; grammatical/semantic edits; retagging; remove opinion poll.
Source Link
Todd A. Jacobs
  • 50.7k
  • 7
  • 60
  • 181

How should we assess "Build vs. Buy" for an ERP Buying VS DevelopingSystem?

Background

We are about to make a huge decision and change of ERP, the. The current solution is outdated and failing on us. The burning question is: Do we buy a solution like SAP, PeopleSoft, Oracle or do we extend our already existing sales software with ERP functionallity ?

As iI just said, we already have a custom software solution which is being used in almost the whole company, we. We also have 3 developers working on this. We are only intrestedinterested in the financial/accounting part of an ERP system, so iI am not talking about a complete ERP.

The other option is to buy an ERP system and come up with some kind of interface between our sales software and the ERP system. According to SAP this is posiblepossible.

I came up with some pro'spros and cons:

Custom Solution:

  • 100% fits business needs
  • Cheap customization
  • 1 solution for the entire company
  • Flexibility in future changes
  • Low initial investment
  • We can make it so that the people using it don't have to change the way they are used to work.

Vendor Solution:

  • Faster implementation
  • Less risk

Build vs. Buy Analysis

If you have experience implementing systems like this or youI already have moresome pros/cons to add to the list and cons listed, please let me knowbut don't have a formal risk assessment.

Thanks ! What is a workable process for comparing a build vs. buy decision for this type of project?

ERP Buying VS Developing

We are about to make a huge decision and change of ERP, the current solution is outdated and failing on us. The burning question is: Do we buy a solution like SAP, PeopleSoft, Oracle or do we extend our already existing sales software with ERP functionallity ?

As i just said we already have a custom software solution which is being used in almost the whole company, we also have 3 developers working on this. We are only intrested in the financial/accounting part of an ERP system, so i am not talking about a complete ERP.

The other option is to buy an ERP system and come up with some kind of interface between our sales software and the ERP system. According to SAP this is posible.

I came up with some pro's and cons:

Custom Solution:

  • 100% fits business needs
  • Cheap customization
  • 1 solution for the entire company
  • Flexibility in future changes
  • Low initial investment
  • We can make it so that the people using it don't have to change the way they are used to work.

Vendor Solution:

  • Faster implementation
  • Less risk

If you have experience implementing systems like this or you have more pros/cons to add to the list, please let me know.

Thanks !

How should we assess "Build vs. Buy" for an ERP System?

Background

We are about to make a huge decision and change of ERP. The current solution is outdated and failing on us. The burning question is: Do we buy a solution like SAP, PeopleSoft, Oracle or do we extend our already existing sales software with ERP functionallity ?

As I just said, we already have a custom software solution which is being used in almost the whole company. We also have 3 developers working on this. We are only interested in the financial/accounting part of an ERP system, so I am not talking about a complete ERP.

The other option is to buy an ERP system and come up with some kind of interface between our sales software and the ERP system. According to SAP this is possible.

I came up with some pros and cons:

Custom Solution:

  • 100% fits business needs
  • Cheap customization
  • 1 solution for the entire company
  • Flexibility in future changes
  • Low initial investment
  • We can make it so that the people using it don't have to change the way they are used to work.

Vendor Solution:

  • Faster implementation
  • Less risk

Build vs. Buy Analysis

I already have some pros and cons listed, but don't have a formal risk assessment. What is a workable process for comparing a build vs. buy decision for this type of project?

Source Link
Azox
  • 143
  • 5

ERP Buying VS Developing

We are about to make a huge decision and change of ERP, the current solution is outdated and failing on us. The burning question is: Do we buy a solution like SAP, PeopleSoft, Oracle or do we extend our already existing sales software with ERP functionallity ?

As i just said we already have a custom software solution which is being used in almost the whole company, we also have 3 developers working on this. We are only intrested in the financial/accounting part of an ERP system, so i am not talking about a complete ERP.

The other option is to buy an ERP system and come up with some kind of interface between our sales software and the ERP system. According to SAP this is posible.

I came up with some pro's and cons:

Custom Solution:

  • 100% fits business needs
  • Cheap customization
  • 1 solution for the entire company
  • Flexibility in future changes
  • Low initial investment
  • We can make it so that the people using it don't have to change the way they are used to work.

Vendor Solution:

  • Faster implementation
  • Less risk

If you have experience implementing systems like this or you have more pros/cons to add to the list, please let me know.

Thanks !